An electric car usually costs more to insure in Canada than a gas car. Surex, an online insurance marketplace, analyzed a year of quotes on its platform and reported in September 2025 that EVs averaged $3,131.43 a year against $2,289.27 for gas vehicles, a 36.8% difference. How much of that gap reaches you depends on the car and on the province.
The model can matter more than the powertrain. Rates.ca ran quotes for a 35-year-old Toronto man with a clean record, collision and comprehensive coverage and no discounts, and Canadian Underwriter reported them on March 6, 2026. A Tesla Model Y Long Range came in at $2,606 a year, inside the $2,578 to $3,126 range Rates.ca found for compact gas cars from the Toyota Corolla Hatchback to the Honda Civic Si. A Fiat 500e was $2,171. A Hyundai Ioniq 5 N AWD reached up to $4,039.
The province sets the structure around that price. British Columbia, Saskatchewan and Manitoba sell basic coverage through a public insurer. Quebec insures injuries publicly and leaves vehicle damage to private companies. Ontario, Alberta and Atlantic Canada run private markets under provincial rules.
Key takeaways
- Surex's September 2025 analysis of a year of quotes on its platform found EVs averaged $3,131.43 a year to insure, against $2,289.27 for gas cars, a 36.8% difference.
- The model moves the price: Rates.ca's March 2026 Toronto quotes ran from $2,171 for a Fiat 500e to up to $4,039 for a Hyundai Ioniq 5 N, with a Tesla Model Y Long Range at $2,606.
- Repair cost is the main driver. Mitchell puts the average repairable battery-electric claim in Canada in 2025 at $7,253, against $5,659 for a gas vehicle.
- ICBC prices Basic mainly on the driver and Optional on the vehicle's make, model and repair costs, so an EV's repair bill shows up in Optional. Basic rates are frozen through spring 2027.
- Ask for EV discounts: TD Insurance offers 10%, Beneva advertises up to 15%, and Co-operators says EV drivers may be eligible for an automatic discount.
Why EVs cost more to insure
The Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) says the method is the same for every powertrain. "Premiums would be calculated in the same way, whether it's an electric or combustion-powered vehicle," Rob de Pruis of IBC told The Globe and Mail in November 2023. What differs is the claims bill. Insurers use IBC's Canadian Loss Experience Automobile Rating (CLEAR) system to estimate how likely a model is to have a claim and what that claim will cost, with separate ratings for collision, comprehensive, accident benefits and direct compensation for property damage.
The clearest Canadian cost numbers come from Mitchell, an auto physical damage technology company that tracks claims in the U.S. and Canada. Its "Plugged-In: EV Collision Insights" review of 2025, published February 19, 2026, puts the average repairable battery-electric claim in Canada at $7,253, against $5,659 for a gas vehicle, about 28% more. Mitchell ties the difference to dense electrical architectures and sensor-heavy designs that need extra diagnostic and calibration work after a crash. It counted 1.70 calibrations per estimate for battery-electric vehicles in 2025, against 1.54 for gas vehicles.
A written-off car is the other side of the bill, and EVs are worth more. Mitchell's average market value on battery-electric total losses in Canada was $36,504 in 2025, against $16,005 for gas vehicles. Write-offs were not more frequent, at least in 2023. In an April 2024 column for Electric Autonomy, Mitchell's Ryan Mandell reported that EVs in Canada were written off 5.71% of the time in 2023, against 6.77% for gas vehicles from the 2021 model year onward, and that "the incidence of collision-related battery damage is actually quite low." Surex lists battery replacement cost among the reasons an EV can be written off, and notes that insurers hold less claims history on EVs than on gas cars.
Premiums have been moving up faster for EVs. Rates.ca's quote data for the first quarter of 2025 showed EV premiums up 18.9% from a year earlier, against 7.8% for other vehicles. In the March 2026 study, Rates.ca's Daniel Ivans said premiums "reflect the repair and replacement costs insurers are seeing today."
New models start with little data: IBC says newer vehicles often lack enough claims experience, so CLEAR leans on supplementary data until their record builds up. BYD, Chery, Geely and Xpeng do not sell passenger cars under their own names in Canada, so Canadian insurers have no claims history of their own for those models yet, although Chinese-built EVs can now enter under a 49,000-vehicle annual quota at a 6.1% tariff in effect since March 1, 2026. Our guide to Chinese EVs in Canada covers what the quota allows.
BC, Saskatchewan and Manitoba: public basic coverage
British Columbia. ICBC sells Basic Autoplan, the mandatory coverage for every vehicle in the province. It includes $200,000 in third-party liability, Enhanced Accident Benefits with no overall limit, and Underinsured Motorist Protection of up to $1 million per insured person. Basic does not repair your own car after a crash you caused; that is optional Collision coverage.
That split matters for an EV. ICBC prices Basic mainly on the driver: location, crash history, how the vehicle is used and who else drives it. For Optional coverage, ICBC says "the age, make, model and other safety features of your vehicle, along with its repair and potential replacement costs" set the price. An EV with expensive repairs therefore shows up in the Optional premium. Basic itself is frozen: the BC government announced on October 28, 2025, that there would be no increase to Basic rates through spring 2027, the seventh consecutive year without one. Optional coverage can be bought from ICBC or from private insurers that compete for it, so the Optional part is the one to compare.
Saskatchewan. Plate insurance from SGI comes with registration. SGI's driver's handbook says it provides up to $200,000 in liability coverage, covers "loss of, or damage to, your vehicle and its equipment" above a deductible, and includes personal injury benefits. Extended coverage, for replacement cost or a rental car, is bought separately through an insurer or broker. EV owners pay one more charge at the same counter: the province's road use charge on electric vehicles, $300 a year since June 1, 2025, collected by SGI at registration and indexed to inflation from January 1, 2027. It is a road charge, not an insurance premium, but it belongs in the yearly cost.
Gear worth having
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns a small commission from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.

NOCO Boost Plus GB40 Jump Starter
A 1000A lithium jump starter that fits in your glovebox and works on any 12V battery. Your insurance against a dead 12V in a parking lot.
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.
Manitoba. MPI's Basic Autopac is required and, in MPI's words, "includes personal injury insurance, all-perils insurance and third-party liability insurance." Autopac Options can be added on top, and MPI sells Autopac through more than 300 independent agents. As in Saskatchewan, damage to your own vehicle is covered inside the public basic plan, above a deductible, so repairs to your own car are paid by the public plan and not only by optional coverage.
Quebec, Ontario, Alberta and Atlantic Canada
Quebec. The SAAQ's public plan compensates injury or death in a road accident for every Quebecer on a no-fault basis, "regardless of who is responsible," and victims cannot sue the at-fault party. Vehicle damage is private. Quebec law requires owners to carry civil liability insurance of at least $50,000 for property damage they cause to others, and coverage for damage to your own car comes from the same private insurers. The public plan is funded partly by insurance contributions: the SAAQ's 2026 table lists $66.01 on a passenger vehicle registration and $86.16 on a Class 5 licence without demerit points, cut to $21.54 by a 75% rebate. Beneva, a Quebec insurer, advertises up to 15% off car insurance for electric and plug-in hybrid vehicles.
Ontario. Private insurers set rates under the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA). Surex's Ontario averages were $2,932.72 for an EV and $2,464.18 for a gas car, a gap of about 19%, the narrowest of the four provinces in its published breakdown. The policy itself changed on July 1, 2026. Medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits stay mandatory, while income replacement, non-earner, caregiver, death and funeral benefits, among others, became optional. Auto insurance now also pays first for medical and rehabilitation costs, except medication, ahead of workplace or private health plans. IBC notes that existing policies renew with their current coverage unless you agree otherwise in writing.
Alberta. Surex's highest EV average was Alberta's: $3,342.93 against $2,344.19 for gas, about 43% more. The Government of Alberta caps 2026 rate increases at 7.5% for good drivers who qualify. From January 1, 2027, the province moves to its Care-First system, under which people injured in a collision get enhanced benefits "without the need to sue," and a new cap stops insurers from raising average rates by more than 5%, with renewals for average drivers capped at 10%.
Atlantic Canada. New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland and Labrador run private markets. Surex put New Brunswick at $2,769.36 for an EV against $1,704.76 for gas, and Nova Scotia at $3,009.30 against $1,608.95, the widest gap in its breakdown at about 87%. Surex published no figures for PEI, Newfoundland and Labrador or the territories.
Surex's numbers are averages of quotes requested on one marketplace over 12 months, not of policies sold across the market. They show the direction of the gap, not what a single quote will be.
Gear worth having
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns a small commission from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.

Roadside Emergency Safety Kit
Jumper cables, a portable air compressor, tow strap, first aid, and more for when something goes wrong between chargers. Canadian winters do not forgive the unprepared.
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.
Gear worth having
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns a small commission from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.

Grizzl-E Classic Level 2 EV Charger (40A)
Canadian-made and rated for minus 40C winters. 40A / 9.6 kW, NEMA 14-50, indoor/outdoor, 24-ft cable. The charger built for Canadian weather.
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.
How to lower an EV insurance quote
- Quote the car before you buy it. Among EVs alone, Rates.ca's Toronto quotes ran from $2,171 to up to $4,039 for the same driver. As Ivans put it, "insurance pricing isn't uniform across electric vehicles."
- Get several quotes. In Ontario, Alberta and Atlantic Canada the whole policy is competitive. In BC, Basic comes from ICBC and Optional can be compared. In Saskatchewan and Manitoba, compare the extension coverage.
- Ask about EV discounts by name. TD Insurance applies its 10% Green Wheel Discount to private passenger vehicles identified as hybrid or electric in IBC's vehicle description tables. Beneva advertises up to 15%. Co-operators says hybrid and electric vehicle drivers "may be eligible for an automatic discount."
- Ask where the car would be repaired. TD says select TD Insurance Auto Centres are EV-certified and that it will repair or replace an EV battery damaged in an accident as part of coverage, subject to policy conditions. Ask any insurer whether its preferred shops are certified by the automaker for your model, and whether a rental after a claim can be an EV.
- In Ontario, read the accident benefits section. Since July 1, 2026, two quotes can differ simply because one includes optional benefits the other leaves out.
Insurance is one line in the running cost of an EV. Our EV vs gas total cost of ownership analysis sets it next to fuel, maintenance and depreciation, and our EV rebates by province breakdown covers the purchase incentives.
Correction, November 9, 2026: An earlier version of this article gave premium ranges by city and province, claim-severity figures, insurer rate filings, decline rates and discounts, and EV rate increases at ICBC, MPI and SGI that could not be verified, and described an insurer surcharge on BYD, Chery, Geely and Xpeng vehicles, which are not sold in Canada. Those passages have been removed; the figures that remain are sourced in the text.
Gear worth having
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns a small commission from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.

VIOFO A229 Pro 4K Dash Cam
4K front plus 2K rear with parking mode and GPS. Your silent witness for insurance claims, with always-on sentry recording while parked.
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.
Gear worth having
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns a small commission from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.

TP-Link Kasa Smart Plug with Energy Monitoring
Track exactly how much electricity your Level 1 charger uses and schedule it for off-peak hours. Know your real cost per kWh.
As an Amazon Associate, ThinkEV earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.

Founder & Chief Editor
Vlad Pereira is the founder and chief editor of ThinkEV.ca, the Canadian electric vehicle publication he writes and edits from Courtenay, British Columbia. A former professional ballet dancer, he also works as a digital artist, graphic designer, and web and systems developer through his studio, Vlad Pereira Online. He covers EV pricing, rebates, charging costs and the brands entering Canada from the buyer's side.
Frequently asked questions
Why does EV insurance cost more than gas-vehicle insurance in Canada?
Which Canadian province has the cheapest EV insurance?
Are Chinese EVs more expensive to insure in Canada?
Does ICBC charge more to insure an EV?
How do I find the cheapest EV insurance in my area?
Will EV insurance premiums in Canada drop over time?
More EV & road-trip finds
Affordable upgrades worth a look — tap any to check the price on Amazon.
★ 61Toddler Car Seat Snack and Cup Tray
View on Amazon
★ 17,839Qifutan Vent Phone Mount (Military-Grade Clip)
View on Amazon
★ 12,051Windex Electronics Screen Wipes
View on Amazon
★ 55LED Car Door Logo Projector Light
View on Amazon
★ 4,0556-Speed Manual Shift Knob Display
View on Amazon
★ 979Leather Headrest Purse Hook
View on Amazon
★ 55,938WixGear Magnetic Air Vent Phone Mount (2-Pack)
View on Amazon
★ 87Car Window Sun Shades for Kids (4-Pack)
View on AmazonRead, Plan, Then Stay Current
Explore our expert articles to understand incentives and ownership costs, use the map to pressure-test charging reality, then subscribe so new EV coverage comes straight to you.
Continue Reading

Kia EV3 Canada Price: $36,995 Makes It the Cheapest New BEV

Why Legacy Automakers Keep Losing to Chinese EV Brands
MG: From British Icon to Europe's EV Powerhouse

When Is BYD Coming to Canada? No Date or Price Yet

Chinese EVs in Canada: 15,603 In, Still No BYD

